players like Gothic 1 Remake more than Gothic 1 Classic
by where each lands in players' personal rankings
57% put Gothic 1 Remake higher
4 of 7 players who ranked both games have Gothic 1 Remake above Gothic 1 Classic in their own library (1 more own both but never told them apart)
Gothic 1 Remake wins when they meet, too
all 2 direct duels went to Gothic 1 Remake
2 duels between exactly these two. the verdict above rests on everyone's full rankings; this is only what happened when both were on screen together.
this matchup last moved
>> the verdict in words what the duels say about gothic 1 classic vs gothic 1 remake
Players like Gothic 1 Remake more than Gothic 1 Classic, clearly. Gothic 1 Remake beats 75% of the games in a typical Steam library, which ranks it #429 of 19,274 scored games; Gothic 1 Classic beats 52% and ranks #5,458 of 19,274. Gothic 1 Classic's score rests on 51 players, Gothic 1 Remake's on 27 players.
Of the 7 players who ranked both games, 57% put Gothic 1 Remake higher in their own library and 43% Gothic 1 Classic. When they meet on screen together, Gothic 1 Remake wins: 2 of 2 direct duels went its way.
37% of Gothic 1 Classic's raters keep it in the top 30% of their own library, against 63% for Gothic 1 Remake. Gothic 1 Remake is the safer pick: 19% of its raters file it in their bottom 40%, against 37% for Gothic 1 Classic.
Both are tagged RPG, Gothic and Fantasy on Steam; Gothic 1 Classic came out in 2001, Gothic 1 Remake in 2026.
Every score here comes from players duelling games out of their own Steam library, not from reviews or playtime, and this matchup last moved 1 week ago. A new duel on either game can change who wins.
