Stardew Valley vs My Time at Sandrock

players like My Time at Sandrock more than Stardew Valley

by where each lands in players' personal rankings

Stardew Valley

winner

My Time at Sandrock

Stardew Valley

beats 74.5%

#217 of 19,174

based on 815 players

where its players rank it

My Time at Sandrock

beats 75%

#299 of 19,174

based on 47 players

where its players rank it

players who ranked both

60% put Stardew Valley higher

18 of 30 players who ranked both games have Stardew Valley above My Time at Sandrock in their own library (10 more own both but never told them apart)

18 Stardew Valley

My Time at Sandrock 12

head to head

but when they meet, Stardew Valley wins

all 2 direct duels went to Stardew Valley

2 Stardew Valley

My Time at Sandrock 0

2 duels between exactly these two. the verdict above rests on everyone's full rankings; this is only what happened when both were on screen together.

this matchup last moved 1 hour ago

both tagged Farming Sim · Life Sim · RPG · Simulation

[[ most loved · most hated · most controversial ]]

>> the verdict in words what the duels say about stardew valley vs my time at sandrock

Players like My Time at Sandrock more than Stardew Valley, by a hair. My Time at Sandrock beats 75% of the games in a typical Steam library, which ranks it #299 of 19,174 scored games; Stardew Valley beats 75% and ranks #217 of 19,174. Both are well liked, so this is a question of which one players love more, not whether Stardew Valley is any good. Stardew Valley's score rests on 815 players, My Time at Sandrock's on 47 players.

Of the 30 players who ranked both games, 60% put Stardew Valley higher in their own library and 40% My Time at Sandrock. That goes against the site-wide verdict: people who own both lean the other way from the crowd at large. When they meet on screen together, though, Stardew Valley wins: 2 of 2 direct duels went its way.

54% of Stardew Valley's raters keep it in the top 30% of their own library, against 57% for My Time at Sandrock. Stardew Valley is the safer pick: 20% of its raters file it in their bottom 40%, against 26% for My Time at Sandrock.

Both are tagged Farming Sim, Life Sim and RPG on Steam; Stardew Valley came out in 2016, My Time at Sandrock in 2023.

Every score here comes from players duelling games out of their own Steam library, not from reviews or playtime, and this matchup last moved 1 hour ago. A new duel on either game can change who wins.