players like Firewatch more than The Vanishing of Ethan Carter
by where each lands in players' personal rankings
70% put Firewatch higher
7 of 10 players who ranked both games have Firewatch above The Vanishing of Ethan Carter in their own library (5 more own both but never told them apart)
Firewatch wins when they meet, too
all 1 direct duel went to Firewatch
1 duel between exactly these two. the verdict above rests on everyone's full rankings; this is only what happened when both were on screen together.
this matchup last moved
both tagged Mystery · Walking Simulator · Exploration · Adventure
>> the verdict in words what the duels say about the vanishing of ethan carter vs firewatch
Players like Firewatch more than The Vanishing of Ethan Carter, clearly. Firewatch beats 70% of the games in a typical Steam library, which ranks it #914 of 19,275 scored games; The Vanishing of Ethan Carter beats 50% and ranks #7,885 of 19,275. The Vanishing of Ethan Carter's score rests on 30 players, Firewatch's on 146 players.
Of the 10 players who ranked both games, 70% put Firewatch higher in their own library and 30% The Vanishing of Ethan Carter. The one time they met on screen together, the duel went to Firewatch.
23% of The Vanishing of Ethan Carter's raters keep it in the top 30% of their own library, against 50% for Firewatch. Firewatch is the safer pick: 22% of its raters file it in their bottom 40%, against 47% for The Vanishing of Ethan Carter.
Both are tagged Mystery, Walking Simulator and Exploration on Steam; The Vanishing of Ethan Carter came out in 2014, Firewatch in 2016.
Every score here comes from players duelling games out of their own Steam library, not from reviews or playtime, and this matchup last moved 2 hours ago. A new duel on either game can change who wins.
>> more matchups other showdowns with the vanishing of ethan carter or firewatch
